The Fan Favorite prize — typically $100,000 — was started by Sia in 2016. Probst noted the pop star has awarded over $1 million to players since then. Although Probst said in May 2024 that the Sia prize was ending, the show has revived the tradition for this milestone 50th season.
Among those who previously received $100,000 are Rick Devens (38), Elaine Stott (39), Janet Carbin (39), Drea Wheeler (42), Jesse Lopez (43), Carolyn Wiger (44) and Katurah Topps (45). Other contestants awarded varying amounts include Donathan Hurley, Davie Rickenbacker, Aurora McCreary, Joe Anglim, Jamal Shipman, Owen Knight, Ryan Medrano, Lauren Harpe, Carson Garrett, Jake O'Kane and Kaleb Gebrewold.